Trump’s ‘renaming’ of Lake Ontario is emblematic of centuries of colonial erasure

President Donald Trump holds up a signed executive order in the Oval Office of the White House on Aug. 27, 2026, in Washington, D.C. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta) Trump’s ‘renaming’ of Lake Ontario is emblematic of centuries of colonial erasure Published: August 28, 2026 6.26pm EDT Share article Print article The ongoing economic spat between Canada and the United States took a strange turn after U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order “renaming” Lake Ontario as Lake America. The lake is the second body of water to be renamed by Trump. In January 2025, he similarly ordered that the Gulf of Mexico be renamed the Gulf of America. That same order also officially changed Alaska’s Mount Denali to its colonial name, Mount McKinley. While many might view Trump’s renamings as comical or unserious, for Indigenous communities, they are reminiscent of centuries of settler-colonial erasure. What’s in a place name? The name Ontario can be traced to the Huron word ontarí:io, a Wyandot (Huron) word meaning “the lake is great/large,” with a root ontar- meaning “lake” and a suffix -io meaning “great/large.” Observant readers might notice that Ohio has the same -io suffix, translating to “large creek.” The first written mention of the name Ontario was in 1641. Of course, the name predates 1641 and has existed for centuries. It is an example of an Indigenous place name that was adopted by European settlers. This, however, is not how all place names were adopted in Canada. Long before European explorers arrived in North America, Indigenous people already had their own ways of naming geographic locations, which were passed down orally by elders. Naming tends to be descriptive, like we find in places in Nunavut such as Aulattivik (peninsulas where animals were hunted) or Qikiqtarjuaq (big island). Europeans also used descriptive language to name some places, think Red River or Great Lakes. Other times, they adapted local Indigenous words, such as Ontario, Saskatoon or Mississauga. In many other cases, however, place naming in North America was done to commemorate people, erasing the original local Indigenous names, such as in Vancouver, Halifax or Washington. Indeed, America itself is named after Amerigo Vespucci, the Italian explorer whom Europeans credited with “discovering” it. Other times, places were simply renamed after a European counterpart; think Nova Scotia or New York/Amsterdam. Although Europeans were almost certainly aware that local…